Meet Our Team

Meet the people behind Phelan Insurance Agency, Inc.

Insurance advisors who truly work for you.

Home » About Our Agency » Meet Our Team

Not all insurance agents are created equal. At Phelan Insurance Agency, Inc., we go out of our way to treat our clients like people and we use our industry experience and diversified knowledge base to protect what you value most.

Versailles Office
Todd Phelan

Todd Phelan
President and CEO
937-526-3111

Extension 128
Jeff Francis

Jeff Francis
COO, Executive Vice President
937-526-3111

Extension 136
Carol Brown

Carol Brown
Information Systems Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 137
Melissa Shappie

Melissa Shappie
Information Systems Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 152
Julia Kremer

Julia Kremer
Receptionist
937-526-3111

Extension 110
Lindsey Burke

Lindsey Burke
Accounting Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 117
Elena Bulcher

Elena Bulcher
Accounting Assistant
937-526-3111

Extension 115
Sara Wagner

Sara Wagner
Senior Quality Control Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 131
Pat Custenborder

Pat Custenborder
Employee Benefit Consultant
937-526-3111

Extension 118
Chris Gigandet

Chris Gigandet
Employee Benefit Consultant
937-526-3111

Extension 153
Karen Murphy

Karen Murphy
Employee Benefits Account Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 116
Megan Willis

Megan Willis
Employee Benefits Account Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 132
Kelsey Yount

Kelsey Yount
Employee Benefits Team
937-526-3111

Extension 159
Tia Grilliot

Tia Grilliot
Employee Benefits Team
937-526-3111

Extension 159
Meagan Kindell

Meagan Kindell
Employee Benefits Team
937-526-3111

Extension 154
Angie DeMange

Angie DeMange
Account Executive
937-526-3111

Extension 150
Damien Richard

Damien Richard
Account Executive
937-526-3111

Extension 151
Noah Richard

Noah Richard
Account Executive
937-526-3111

Extension 129
David Coons

David Coons
Account Executive
937-526-3111

Extension 123
Lorri Wilson

Lorri Wilson
Senior Account Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 124
Breanne  Cregar

Breanne Cregar
Account Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 135
Karen Thobe

Karen Thobe
Account Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 122
Carrie DeMange

Carrie DeMange
Account Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 133
Kristi Setser

Kristi Setser
Account Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 101
Tiffany Morgan

Tiffany Morgan
Account Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 149
Colleen Jones

Colleen Jones
Account Manager
937-526-3111

Extension 121
Kierra Reichert

Kierra Reichert
CSR
937-526-3111

Extension 157
Cindy Langston

Cindy Langston
Personal Insurance Team
937-526-3111

Extension 112
Deb Less

Deb Less
Personal Insurance Team
937-526-3111

Extension 105
West Chester Office
Brent Phelan

Brent Phelan
President and CEO
513-526-3111

Extension 261
Erich Matt

Erich Matt
Account Executive
800-843-3069

Extension 273
Jennifer Allen

Jennifer Allen
Employee Benefits Team
513-526-3111

Extension 274
Sherri Mullins

Sherri Mullins
Personal Insurance Team
513-526-3111

Extension 280
Amanda Phelan

Amanda Phelan
Account Executive
513-526-3111

Extension 264
Aaron Phelan

Aaron Phelan
Claims
513-526-3111

Extension 272
About Our Agency - Phelan Insurance Agency Team Members Standing Outside the Office

Get Started Today

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

Get a Quote